Posts Tagged ‘twitter’

How to Twitter… Naked

Tuesday, May 26th, 2009


New Orleans’ own Naked Pizza (@NAKEDpizza) is changing the minds of experts and engaging its local community - using Twitter - in a profitable way.  Naked Pizza is effectively using Twitter for communications, customer service and most importantly, new sales.

For anyone who’s been hiding under a rock the last 6 months or so, Twitter is the preeminent micro-blogging service.  Originally designed around limitations of cell-phone carrier SMS messages to 140 characters, Twitter and its peers provide a very brief messaging platform which has grown to accommodate hundreds of other applications which use Twitter as a backbone.

There has been a LOT written about Twitter in general and as a marketing and branding tool.  But as yet, there is no primer, no “Twitter for Business for Dummies.”

Even without a primer Jeff Leach, co-owner of Naked Pizza, seems to be well on the way to figuring it out.  That’s not to say that Jeff’s approach would map to the “best practices” of Public Relations (PR) and Social Media (SM) pros but it’s working for @NAKEDpizza and most importantly Jeff is tying it to metrics which matter to his business.

This issue of “metrics” and measuring return on investment (ROI) is hindering adoption of Social Media tools in larger businesses.  Quoting from Last Wednesday night’s inaugural #pr20chat on Twitter:

Social Media ROI Discussion

Social Media ROI Discussion

Social Media Return on Investment discussion on #PR20Chat.

Jeff is feeling good about his Twitter ROI and he’s got the numbers to prove it.  And, importantly for Jeff, it’s hyper-local.  NAKED Pizza is primarily using Twitter to market to an area with a 3 mile radius. Or as Jeff said when we talked about his sign, “I didn’t do it to get TechCrunch talking, I did it to reach the 35,000 people who drive by the store every day.”

Naked Pizza Twitter Sign Going up

Naked Pizza Twitter Sign Going up

Oh right, I may not have mentioned that: Naked Pizza is apparently the first company, period, to replace its old billboard with one calling out for Twitter followers.  And as you can imagine it’s getting a lot of attention.

Clearly a smart guy, Leach realizes there’s more gold in them thar hills, and with Naked’s aspirations toward a national franchise strategy, all PR is good PR.  But from a dollars and cents view, the @NAKEDpizza Twitter strategy is showing its potential.

With his first concerted effort at a Twitter-only promotion, Leach was able to drive 15% of daily revenues with Twitter.  And of those 15%, 90% were new customers!  Not bad for a guy who didn’t even have an account until 5 weeks ago.

And, here’s the crazy part, it’s all him.  No high-falutin’ PR firm.  No “Social Media Expert”, just a guy on a mission to change the world one pizza at a time.
Sure, Robbie Vitrano (@robbievitrano) of the Trumpet Group (a well-known branding and marketing firm) is a friend and advisor, but the Twitter strategy is all Jeff, precipitated by an offhanded remark from Mark Cuban (@mcuban) suggesting he thought there was “something to it”.

When asked, Robbie Vitrano had this to say:

What NAKEDpizza “gets” - and they get it - is that in today’s marketplace there isn’t enough money to buy attention.  But you can earn it by being purposeful, authentic, willing to make mistakes, and most importantly, by having the ability to shut up and listen.  The [Twitter] sign is an example of what the greatest natural marketers bake into their entrepreneurial vision — the courage to believe in your mission.  Twitter is a pretty jiffy tool.  But it’s just that.  First, you have to have something to say.  You’ll quickly find out “beaucoup” as we say in NOLA, if what you have to say is interesting and useful.  Check and check.

So, what are the goals for this local business on twitter?  Jeff Leach (@NAKEDpizza) says it best:

“I needed to drive down cost of marketing.  ROI of other media suck [sic].”

“The average Papa John’s does email, door hangers, hard direct mail.  [We were] looking for a way to leverage emerging social media — [there's] no TV attention, radio is too broad and our coverage area is too small.  We wanted to target the store’s delivery area, everyone around us in 3 mile radius.  ROI on direct mail is getting lower / lower.  Even Big Jimmy’s barbeque has an email newsletter.  Email open rates are dropping, too.”

Some people have taken Mark Cuban’s involvement to mean that Naked Pizza needed help. As it turns out, they were already profitable and one would guess this level of engagement will assure they continue to be.

What the Cuban investment enables - in addition to enabling Mark to develop Texas - is expansion into new markets by franchise.  And, as anyone who has been involved in franchises knows there are rules and systems.  The systems support the developer in replicating the success of the original.
With this in mind I asked Jeff “Does the facility with social media become a requirement for an area developer”?

His answer:

“We won’t sell an area developer deal to a guy who can’t identify who that general manager is going to be and that the GM owns part of the business.  An investor must manage or GM must be invested.

“GM must demonstrate facility with new media.

“As we get our social media legs we’re going to have to prepare to cross that bridge by late summer.”

So what’s next, then, for Naked Pizza and social media?  Jeff indicates to me that he’s been given access to some beta tools and is actively engaged in other top-secret discussions which will enable some pretty exhaustive customer analysis such as “Let’s say Will Scott (@w2scott) orders twice a month (it’s actually more like 4X).  Follows us on Twitter, is a fan on Facebook and is getting my newsletter.  Instead of spending money on physical contact, how do I avoid sending to those already following.”

It should be clear at this point that this is something in which Jeff is personally very invested.  Certainly he’s drawing a crowd of evangelists, but this is a lot of hard work.

Thinking of that, I asked Jeff some follow-up questions by email:

Q: “What does it look like when you reach a saturation point and have to delegate to maintain velocity”?

A: “Given the importance… having the top dogs in our company control that becomes even more important. Our brand is everything. For the next year, the most important thing we can do is have the actual owners experience and learn from this environment - then, and only then, will we truly understand its utility and limitations. Having an employee, intern, or even a marketing company handle our SM makes little sense. That strategy would not result in any real learning or enhanced experience for our customers. Anyone other than the founders and top people… do not possess the breadth of understanding of our mission and lack the context of all the moving parts as we adapt and ‘evolve forward.’ By experiencing this myself, I can apply all that is social media to what we are doing - always looking for an opportunity. Anyone other than me and my partner (Randy Crochet) might miss it.

“Is it healthy?  Is it good for the environment? Was anyone harmed in the procurement of these goods? And so on.

“Through tools such as cotweet… we can “eventually” - though not now - delegate more customer service type inquiries. Interestingly, as we open new locations throughout the country, the challenge will be how we structure our social media at these various locations. We will, of course, have corporate flow but will also require a local feel for each location. Having said that, we will probably be the first franchise company in the country that actually makes ones social media skills and capabilities one of the requirements to be awarded one of our Area Developers Agreements. In other words, money and operational skills are not enough: u must have and possess a grasp of social media and how it operates inside our Pavlov Marketing Plan in order to be our partner. In the Franchising 2.0 world, these skills and  understanding of the evolution of customers will probably be more important than the fact u ran similar businesses for 20 years etc. This means we will probably seek out (and we already have) savvy, younger, and smarter partners.”

“The world is gonna be a better place and we want to be part of it.”

Q:     ”How does your current behavior + your methods of delegation become a template for other small-biz”?

A:  “As for how this becomes a template for other small biz? Have no idea. Social Media is different things to different businesses. I think social media will make entrepreneurs and [their customers] think very hard about what they are selling and whether or not it jives with how people think and will be thinking in the future.

So, there you have it.  Jeff doesn’t have the primer.  We still need to write that “Small Business Social Media for Dummies” book.

Naked Pizza has proven, and continues to prove, that a mission, real engagement and a willingness to be who you are online will drive loyalty and evangelism.

And, 15% of daily sales isn’t enough for Jeff and the Naked Pizza team:

“@NAKEDpizza: c’mon order a few pizzas for eat like an ancestor day. shooting for twitter sales record http://bit.ly/iJYjU”.

Is it local search, or is it word of mouth?  In the final analysis we don’t know its impact on local search  (yet), but the impact on Naked Pizza’s bottom line and the Small Business Social Media psyche is undeniable.

Follow Will Scott (@w2scott) and I’ll let you know when we’ve got that Social Media Small Business primer written.

I’m hungry, it may be time to order some more Naked Pizza.

Twitter: The Local Monetization Strategy

Wednesday, April 8th, 2009

Over the last couple months we have heard many different ideas on how Twitter can successfully monetize their surge in popularity, growing user base, and overall traffic. The ideas range from charging for an account, charging for premium accounts, simply adding AdSense, and the list goes on. What we haven’t heard is how Twitter could add local search into their business model, monetize it successfully, and create more user generated content.

When you think about it almost everything that is on Twitter is inherently local. The simple question “What are you doing?” implies that because, unless you are at home watching TV, you are doing something that is local, whether that is local to you or to someone else. The obvious example of this is when you go out to a restaurant and write about that on Twitter, whether you say “Going out to [insert name here] with @stevemcstud” or “Just had a great dinner with @stevemcstud at [insert name here]“. If you simply perform a search on Twitter for “restaurant in”, the point being to see how many people tweet “I am going to restaurant in [insert city]” or “Anybody know of a good restaurant in [insert city name]?” you can see that with just that one phrasing there are tons of results of people talking about local restaurants.

With restaurants being one of the biggest categories in local search as far as traffic and advertisers, it would be easy to roll out a beta test for this to justify whether local would work for Twitter or no. So how do I propose Twitter take advantage of this? Create Business Twitter pages. Just like Facebook, where the page does not have as much functionality as a real Facebook but simply serves the purpose of people being able to connect and talk about a subject. Twitter can simply buy the data of all the restaurants in San Franscico and publish them with static pages so that people can actually say “I just ate @lunchbox with @stevemcstud and it was great!” instead of actual tweets like this:

tweet1

@dudeman718 could of actually told @SoulPSuperstar where he went rather than a “sushi restaurant in Maple Shade, NJ” and they could of actually clicked on @[restaurant name] and gone and looked at a Business Twitter page. What would a Business Twitter page look like you might say. Like this:

twitter-example

Traffic
With this type of page it requires absolutely no action by the restaurant owner or anyone at the restaurant. Twitter would easily be able to kill it in the SERPs if they structured the business pages into a well done SEO friendly directory which would help users find restaurants in their city. Sooner rather than later you would see twitter showing up for searches like “Restaurants in San Francisco” with all that link juice and fresh content it is no question. This would drive an amazing amount of traffic to Twitter, my guess would be about 4-6 million more visits via search engine traffic with this fully deployed.

Small Business Accounts

Besides the new traffic this would allow business owners who don’t know about Twitter to sign up for it. Business owners always at some point perform vanity searches for their business name, in which Twitter would show up in the results in Google and then they would sign up after seeing all the reviews people are writing about their business. Twitter then could charge for business accounts and then monetize the business account that are not claimed by featuring claimed businesses on other related business accounts that are not claimed, something like a “You Might Also Like” type feature.

User Experience and Advertising
buy lisinopril
By implementing this you get a huge double benefit. You get to charge businesses for accounts which would generate revenue. Then you also get to rank the directory by Twitter buzz, allow users to tell other users what they are doing more accurately and with less characters, and create more user generated content overall. With people doing nothing but saying what is on there mind on Twitter, they can easily pass Yelp! as far as content is concerned while keeping their original model as a web app intact and not selling out but rather adding a needed feature, the website.

Partnerships
Partnerships will come flooding in with the likes of Superpages.com, City Search, and others. Twitter will not have to complicate their business with a sales force, but just partner with the giants in the local industry who already have the customers, their credit cards, and revenue coming from what exactly small businesses want, more customers. With traffic coming in from local searches, reviews, and buzz, companies with have to partner with Twitter just to keep up with the industry.

It’s All Bout The Dolla Bills
So how much money can this actually bring to Twitter? The current valuation has Twitter worth about $250,000,000, last time I checked, and that was based solely on the buzz and the amount of users they have on the site. With an estimated 6,000,000 visits a month coming from this program and a majority of them will no doubt be recovery searches (people or business owners searching for business names, phone numbers, addresses etc.) this will get Twitter in the public eye to consumers and businesses owners doing vanity searches. There is no doubt that a percentage of those new visits will end up signing up for the service.

With the current valuations, the actual worth of each Twitter user is debated to be between $73 and $42, so let’s just say $40 to be safe. If only 2% of my estimated 6,000,000 new hits per month actually sign up for the service that will total 120,000 new users every month. So what is 120,000 users worth at the current valuation? $4,800,000. And that number grows every month with new sign ups and new visits. Now I realize that not every single one of the 6,000,000 visits every month will be brand new every time, but without a doubt from my experience of working with Local Search Destination Sites the majority of them will be.

The number above does not even take into account the monthly residual they could make from small businesses that they sign up through partnerships. From pure revenue stand point they can easily get 50,000 small business clients spending $6 per month. So let’s assume that they have a 50/50 revenue split. They receive $150,000 per month and growing residual income from partnerships. Now if we apply the math we did above with each user worth $40 then these 50,000 new paying customers add a value of $2,000,000 to the company as well.

Conclusion
All and all this is what you get:

  • A better user experience where you will see tweets like “Just had lunch @LunchBox with @SteveMcStud” rather than “Just had lunch with @SteveMcstud at that one cafe at Google next to the main campus”
  • They will increase there traffic generated by search engines by at least 4-6 million per month.
  • Business owners will find there pre-made Twitter accounts, take them over, and interact with the Twitter community
  • Partnerships will follow with companies that already have the very businesses that people on Twitter are talking about actually paying them money. No sales force required.
  • Revenue. You actually have a profitable revenue source that may not be the end all be all model, but will be a huge chuck of revenue that does not interrupt the user experience but actually makes it better.
  • A big increase in valuation due to increased revenue, increased user base, and increased market share.

So that is my 2 cents. For all I know I could be completely wrong. Oh yeah, by the way, in the hour it took me to finish this article there have been 65 more people who had “restaurant in” in their tweets.